The Digital Contrarian™

Ryan Levesque

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Contrarian insights directly to your inbox.

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Contrarian insights directly to your inbox.
The Digital Contrarian™

Ryan Levesque

Issue #123

| The Digital Contrarian™

The Great American Apple LIE…

The Great American Apple LIE: The Danger of Soundbites, Personality Tests, & What AI Tells You... About You.

Ryan Levesque

9 min read

-

“An apple a day keeps the doctor ________.”
 
You could finish that sentence in your sleep, right? One of those bits of wisdom we absorbed so early, we can’t even remember ever learning it.
 
There’s just one problem…
 
It’s not quite true.
 
Or at least, it’s not the whole story.
 
The saying actually started as a 19th century Welsh folk rhyme:
 
“Eat an apple on going to bed, and you’ll keep the doctor from earning his bread.”
 
So how did a Welsh bedtime rhyme end up as something every American kid can recite?
 
The answer?
 
Follow the booze…
For most of American history, apples weren’t grown for eating.
 
They were grown for drinking.
 
As Michael Pollan puts it in The Botany of Desire, “Up until Prohibition, an apple grown in America was far less likely to be eaten than to wind up in a barrel of cider.”
 
Then the temperance movement took hold. By one historian’s estimate, Americans drank about 15 gallons of cider per person in the 1820s, and barely 2 gallons by 1840.
Our boys making sweet (non-alcoholic) cider on the farm a few years ago with our friends Jeff and Ana.
And when national Prohibition arrived in 1920, it finished off what was left of the commercial cider business.
 
That left apple growers with a serious problem. Their biggest outlet was drying up, and Americans were eating fewer fresh apples every year.
 
So the growers went to work.
 
They rebranded the apple from a way to get drunk to “The Health Fruit.”
 
And in 1914, an ad for Skookum apples out of Washington State signed off with a line you already know by heart:
 
“An apple a day keeps the doctor away.”
 
The soundbite stuck, and has to this day.
 
But it’s a lie as American as apple pie…

1 | The Danger of Soundbites

In this post-AI world, more and more this is how we take in information:
 
In soundbites.
 
We don’t want to read the whole book. We just want the AI summary.
 
We don’t want to watch the entire video. We just want the 30-second clip.
 
But when we try to reduce an idea (especially one with depth and nuance) to a soundbite, we lose critical context along the way.
 
And context is everything.
 
So we take these soundbites at face value, even they’re not quite true.
 
And this is real danger of soundbites.
 
 
“If books are no longer being read…
 
And our only keyhole into the world is an AI chatbot we rely on to give us the answer to every question…
 
Then we are dangerously close to being fooled… like the fools we are for trusting those answers.”
But the most dangerous soundbite isn’t one about apples.
 
It’s the one about you.

2 | How Well Do You Really "Know Thyself?"

I could not help but notice in choosing this image that the Kolbe Index has a remarkably similar shape to the Shape of Enshittification. An unfortunate coincidence.
There is a certain allure of relying on an assessment to reduce who we are to a number. A Kolbe score. A Love Language. Five signature strengths. An Enneagram type.
 
It’s clean, simple, and shareable.
 
And it’s the entire premise that my last business, The ASK Method Company, was built upon.
 
In fact, the psychology behind the “Quiz Funnel” comes down to one simple truth: it doesn’t matter what market you’re in or what you sell, the thing people care about more than anything else is… themselves.
 
To feel seen, heard, and understood.
 
It’s why personality tests, diagnostics, and assessments are so irresistible. I’ve studied the psychological pull behind this more deeply than almost anyone I know over the last two decades.
But the problem is this:
 
When we try to reduce ourselves to a soundbite like this, we lose something critical in the process. We abdicate the real work.
 
We abdicate what I advocate in Chapter 6 of Return to Real. To Seek & Speak Truth. To learn how to trust to the Contrarian Voice of Your Heart.
 
When we hand the question of “who am I” over to a test, a framework, (or to a chatbot at 2 a.m. on yet another “help me figure out my life” AI bender), we deprive ourselves of the important work of answering this question for ourselves.
 
We rely on the score. We trust what AI comes back with. And before long, we adopt this shorthand as our personality. “I’m a 3 on the Enneagram” or “I’m a high Quick-Start on Kolbe” or “AI says that I should…”
 
Yes, a personality test can be a useful mirror. But it can also be overly simplistic, reducing the complex human being you are into a number, a color, a handful of words…
 
A soundbite.

3 | A Million Ways to Make a Million Dollars.

This week was full of conversations with entrepreneurs, private clients, and colleagues reaching out for advice and words of wisdom. And the same thread kept coming up over and over again.
 
There is no one-size-fits-all answer.
 
Look, if you’re an entrepreneur, there are a million ways to make a million dollars. If you’re an author, there are a million ways to sell a million copies of your book.
 
You have to pick the one that’s right for you.
 
AND the one that’s right for right now.
 
It means knowing thyself: what works for your personality and your way of working. But it also means knowing wherethe world is and what’s working right now.
 
Case in point…
 
Earlier this week, a young entrepreneur asked me what I did when I was at the same stage he’s at now, and I had to start with a caveat.
When I was in my twenties, I was designing sophisticated quiz funnels for businesses in all sorts of different markets, including the sports instruction space. Golf. Basketball. Tennis.
 
In some of those businesses, we had three, five, eight quiz funnels simultaneously running at once, and we were crushing it.
 
Two of the companies I partnered with went on to nine-figure exits.
 
But that was a different time and place. The market was different. The technology was different. The world was different. What made sense to do then doesn’t necessarily make sense today.
 
Success leaves clues. But those clues come with a time and a place…
 
You have to go beyond the soundbite.

4 | Is This True for Me? Is This True For Now?

So the next time you hear a piece of advice (and certainly the next time you stumble upon a short-form soundbite on social media), run it through two questions:
 
  1. Is this true for me?
  2. Is this true for now?
If the answer to either one is no, it may still be wisdom. Perhaps just not for you. Or not at this moment.
 
I’m re-reading The Four Agreements by Don Miguel Ruiz.
 
You probably know the four, even if you’ve never read the book:
 
  1. Be impeccable with your word
  2. Don’t take anything personally
  3. Don’t make assumptions
  4. Always do your best.
In 2010, Ruiz and his son José published the much less well-known follow-up to this work titled The Fifth Agreement, which is the following:
 
  1. Be skeptical, but learn to listen.
Or as it’s expressed in Return to Real:
 
Be Curious. Ask Questions. Seek Truth.
 
In many ways, Return to Real is about more than the last human advantage in an age of artificial everything. It’s an invitation to return to who you really are.
 
So yes, eat the apple. Yes, take the personality test. Yes, ask AI what you should do with your life.
 
Just don’t mistake the soundbite for the truth.
* * *
Okay, I’ll leave you with that for now.
 
Remember to hug the ones you love.
 
And until next week,
 
Ryan :-)
 
P.S. Want to go beyond the soundbite?
 
This Thursday, October 29th, is the third and final session of the Return to Real Roundtable Series, and the topic could not be more fitting:
 
Session #3: Seek & Speak Truth: The Contrarian Advantage
 
The founders that stand out right now are the ones whose unique voice is unmistakable and whose point of view is sharp enough to alienate some people and magnetically attract others.
 
We’ll dig into the ways you can bring this into your marketing and your messaging so you stand out in a sea of AI noise we find ourselves in.
 
In many ways, this entire issue has been about that very thing: seeking the truth about who you really are.
 
If you’ve already ordered the book from our website, you’ll find access in your book bonus area.
If you haven’t ordered your copy yet, now is the perfect opportunity. You can order either the Hardcover Trio or Digital Duo at ReturnToRealBook.com.
 
You’ll get access to the full Roundtable Series (Valued at $179), including instant access to the recordings of the first two sessions.
 
Here is what one reader, Aude-Olivia Dufour, had to say after finishing the book this past week:
I invite you to get your copy today.
 
And if you already have your copy, consider ordering a few additional copies to gift to the person (or people) in your life who could benefit most from this book.
 
P.P.S. One last thing for today before we wrap…
 
In a few weeks, Nov 9–12, as part of my Return to Real book tour, I’ll be teaching at the Baby Bathwater Institute’s Texas Flagship, a gathering of founders I’m proud to be part of.
My session is the following:
Category of One: How to Reposition Your Brand to Be the Clear and Obvious Choice in Your Market in a Post-AI World.
I’ll teach the framework, then work it in real time through live hot seats from within the room.
 
(Fitting, given this week’s theme. You can’t copy a Category of One from someone else. It all starts with knowing who you are…)
 
Baby Bathwater is application-only. If you’re a founder and you’d like to be in the room, you can apply here.
 
This is one of the few groups I’m part of as a paying member.
 
(I don’t get any compensation for introducing the group to you. I just can’t recommend it highly enough.)
 
Be sure to mention my name when you submit your expression of interest.
 
I’d love to see you in the room.
 
All my best,
 
Ryan :-)

Want more insights like these?

Get The Digital Contrarian delivered to your inbox every weekend – before it’s published anywhere else.

Read more newsletters:

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Join over 100K+ readers of The Digital Contrarian getting unconventional business strategies delivered straight to their inbox.

Want more insights like these?

Get The Digital Contrarian delivered to your inbox every weekend – before it’s published anywhere else.

© RL & Associates LLC. All rights reserved.

The Great Sea Change

The Great Sea Change diagram from Return to Real